COLUMN: Duhaime – Time for Quebec to drill its own oil wells

- April 26th, 2012

Drill, baby, drill!

by Eric Duhaime

If Quebecers are sincere and want to stop depending so much on the transfer payments coming from Canada’s richest provinces, they could just start doing what Alberta, Saskatchewan and Newfoundland — the three richest provinces in the country — are doing, and say yes to homemade oil.

Even if most governments in the western world seem obsessed with the idea of adopting cost-ineffective programs to promote so-called green energy sources, like it or not, oil remains the main and most viable resource. Over the past 20 years, our oil consumption has increased. Oil will still be the largest source of primary energy in the world for at least the next few decades. This will remain the case until renewable energies become less expensive.

In the meantime, somebody somewhere needs to extract, refine and sell “dirty” oil. It’s a matter of survival, not just for our cars and trucks, but also for heating, fertilizers, pesticides, synthetic fibres, plastics, solvents, paints, rubber, detergents, cosmetics, medicine, and so on.

The most prosperous provinces in Canada and the wealthiest American states are those exploiting their oil and natural gas resources.

Some other have-not provinces also have great oil potential but do not exploit it. Quebec is one example.

The Montreal Economic Institute (MEI) published a relevant study by Prof. Germain Belzile, entitled “The benefit of oil production development in Quebec.” According to several evaluations, there are more than 46 billion barrels of oil in two locations in Quebec: Anticosti Island and Old Harry.

The MEI conservatively estimates that at $100 a barrel, and assuming that just one-tenth of those reserves were recoverable, Quebec’s potential production worth would be more than $400 billion. And we are not even talking here about the other great unexploited natural resource reserves that Quebec has but refuses to exploit — shale gas.

What would happen if Jean Charest’s government gave a green light to oil development?

“Obviously, the Quebec government would receive royalties, but it would also receive tax revenue from the private income generated by higher growth. This would allow the government to reduce the tax burdens of households and businesses, and might even help it pay back a part of its public debt and escape from its dependence on transfers from the federal equalization program,” Belzile informs us.

For the tree-huggers, we can add that we would take greater care of the environment since we would not need to carry oil from the other end of Canada or, even worse, the Middle East.

Alberta’s average household income in 2009 was $71,600, compared to $50,600 in Quebec. La belle province will not become more “belle” or narrow this gap by depending more and more on its neighbour’s wallet and work.

Quebec’s economic problems have, in fact, nothing to do with the fiscal imbalance of federalism, as separatists claim, and everything to do with its energy and environmental policies.

Instead of screaming and begging for more money from Ottawa and Alberta, why don’t Quebecers roll up their sleeves and start digging for the wealth sitting underneath their feet? Drill, Quebec, drill!

Categories: Contributor Columns

Subscribe to the post

3 comments

  1. John says:

    Great article. Quebec definitely has the resources to be a very rich province. It is only a matter of time until they start to develop and prosper. Old Harry and Anticosti Island have the potential to make Quebec a powerhouse amongst the provinces.

  2. EMO says:

    i would like to see how they safely get oil out of the ground without endangering the environment. this oil deposit is a game changer for our dependence on oil.

  3. JK says:

    I agree with your comments on the environment EMO. However, we are talking about potentially Hundreds of Billions of Dollars worth of Oil on Anticosti Island where the population was 281 on the 2006 census. One should do what one can to be environmental friendly. But to do nothing on an Island of 281 people while the rest of Quebec with 8,000,000 people are asking for handouts from Ottawa does not make sense. Nothing in life is perfect. Quebec clearly has the resources in Anticosti and Old Harry and the time has come for Quebec to develop those resources and reap the benefits for the people of Quebec. Corridor Resources (CDH) is the company with permits on both of thse lands and has been eager to work with the Province to develop these resources in an environmentally friendly way.

Comments are closed.